User Discussion: 17 Hornet vs 17WSM Which one Wins?

| February 12, 2013 | 52 Comments
hunting 17Hvs17WSM 300x300 User Discussion: 17 Hornet vs 17WSM Which one Wins?

Who Wins?

Two new 17cal cartridges have been released by major manufacturers in the last year or so, lets have a look at the 17WSM and the 17 Hornet (by Hornady) and get your opinion on which one (if any or both) will still be here in 5 years.

First up you have the 17 Hornet by Hornady. Originally developed by P O Ackley Hornady started producing this cartridge in 2012. It is based of the 22 Hornet case and is a centrefire cartridge, capable of propelling a 20gn VMax bullet at 3650fps. Brass is reloadable.

The 17WSM or 17 Winchester Super Magnum was announced at the US Shot Show in Las Vegas 2013. Based off of a 27cal nail gun blank case, it will fire a 20gn projectile at 3000 fps. It is a rimfire case and therefore cannot be reloaded.

So we have one Old but new again cartridge in the 17 Hornet that is a reloadable centrefire cartridge then we have the fastest rimfire on the market in the 17WSM.

Which one would you buy?

Which one is still here in 5 years?

Did Winchester make a mistake by calling it a 17 WSM which may confuse it with the lukewarm Winchester Short Magnum centrefire cartridges and the now dead WSSM cartridges of the last decade?

Do you think Winchester could have made it more of a success by starting off with a 20 cal Rimfire rather than push another 17 cal into the rimfire market?

Tell us your opinions below in the comments section

Tags: , , , , ,

Category: Hunting Equipment, Hunting Rifles

Comments (52)

Trackback URL | Comments RSS Feed

  1. Russell says:

    Ouch! I’ve been shooting for 40 years and sincerely sympathise with you, but it does happen that occasionally a rifle will slip through the quality control mechanism of even the better brands. A new Rem 700 once gave me similar results (very surprising). After checking all the usual causes I discovered the bore was not drilled concentric with the barrel. The store replaced it without question and the next confirmed my faith in Remington. I’ve got my fingers crossed that you get a good replacement.

    Ps Some guns ARE worth more than others, but even money can’t buy happiness sometimes. It sounds like the problem is the rifle, not the ammo.

  2. My brother suggested I might like this blog. He was totally right.

    This post truly made my day. You can not imagine simply how
    much time I had spent for this info! Thanks!

Leave a Reply